You're standing in our store (or browsing online) trying to decide between two Christmas village giants. One shelf shows intricate Department 56 porcelain buildings. The other displays colorful Lemax resin pieces at half the price.
Which brand deserves your investment?
After 40+ years selling both brands at Christmas Loft, we've heard every question and seen every collection dilemma. Here's everything you need to know.
Department 56 offers heirloom detail and stronger collectibility. Lemax offers more variety, durability and value. Neither is simply “better”—the right choice depends on how you plan to collect and display.
Quick comparison
| Feature | Department 56 | LeMax |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Porcelain | Resin / polyresin |
| Price range | $60–$250+ per building | $25–$120 per building |
| Detail level | Hand-painted, intricate | Molded detail, painted |
| Durability | Fragile; careful handling | More durable; less breakage |
| Collection value | Higher resale value | Moderate resale value |
| New releases | Annual, limited quantities | Frequent, readily available |
| Best for | Serious collectors | Budget-conscious displayers |

Material & construction
Department 56’s porcelain advantage
Department 56 buildings use porcelain—the same material as fine china. This allows incredibly fine detail: individual bricks, window frames, architectural flourishes that would be impossible in resin.
The hand-painting adds depth. Colors layer and blend naturally rather than looking flat or artificial. When you inspect a Department 56 building up close, you notice details you missed from a distance.
The drawback? Porcelain chips easily. Drop a Department 56 building and you’ll likely need glue. Careful storage becomes essential.
Shop Department 56 porcelain buildings→Lemax’s Resin Practicality
Lemax uses resin or polyresin—a lighter, more forgiving material. Buildings still feature impressive detail, but it’s molded into the material rather than hand-painted on top.
This makes Lemax pieces more durable. Kids and pets pose less risk. The material resists the minor bumps that would damage porcelain.
The trade-off shows in the details. Under close inspection, Lemax buildings sometimes show mold lines or paint that doesn’t capture the same depth as Department 56’s layered approach.
Explore Lemax resin villages →Price point analysis
An heirloom investment
Small buildings: $60–90
Medium buildings: $90–150
Large signature pieces: $150–250+
Retired pieces: Premium prices
A five-to-seven-building display may cost $500–$1,500 before accessories.
More village for the budget
Small buildings: $25–45
Medium buildings: $45–70
Large centerpiece buildings: $70–120
Accessories: $10–30
A comparable display can often be built for $250–$500.
A standard Snow Village house runs $80–$120. Complete your scene with 5–7 buildings and you’re looking at $500–$1,000 before accessories.
Browse Department 56 Snow Village→Build a comparable 5–7 building display for $250–$500. The budget difference matters when you’re starting out or buying gifts.
Shop Lemax villages →
Related Products
25220
23130
22011
Collections & themes
Department 56’s classic lines
Department 56 organizes villages by distinct themes:
Snow Village: American small-town charm from the 1950s–60s. Think diners, gas stations, homes with picket fences. The most versatile collection—pieces work together seamlessly.
Dickens’ Village: Victorian London with Dickensian buildings. Cobblestone scenes and period detail appeal to literature fans.
North Pole Village: Santa’s workshop complex. Whimsical, colorful, perfect for families with young children.
Christmas in the City: Urban brownstones and city storefronts. Sophisticated option for non-traditional decorators.
Each collection maintains a consistent architectural style and scale. Mixing collections works, but staying within one gives the most cohesive result.
See all Department 56 collections →Lemax’s versatile theming
Lemax takes a different approach with broader collection guidelines:
Caddington Village: Traditional European-inspired buildings with more flexibility. Their pastel colors work beyond Christmas.
Vail Village: Winter sports theme with lodges and chalets.
General Christmas: Mix-and-match pieces that don’t require collection consistency. Specialty themes like Halloween also have year-round collectors.
Lemax’s flexibility helps when you want variety without worrying about matching perfectly. The pieces play well together across collections.
Explore Lemax collections →
Lighting & technical features
Both Brands Include Electrical Components In Most Buildings, But Implementation Differs.
Department 56 Uses Standard Bulbs In Their Older Pieces And LEDs In Newer Releases. The Lighting Tends To Be Warmer And Softer—Excellent For Creating Ambiance But Sometimes Less Bright Than Lemax.
Lemax Embraced LEDs Earlier And More Completely. Their Buildings Often Include Brighter, More Dramatic Lighting Effects. Some Pieces Feature Animation, Sound, And Multiple Lighting Modes.
Power Cords And Adapters Differ Between Brands, So Mixing Them Requires Additional Planning For Your Electrical Setup.
Find lighting accessories →
Collectibility & resale value
Department 56 secondary market
Department 56 buildings often appreciate after retirement. Rare pieces from popular collections command significant premiums. Active collector communities buy, sell, and trade retired pieces. Original boxes and accessories impact value considerably.
Lemax market reality
Lemax pieces typically don’t appreciate the same way. The higher production numbers and continued availability limit secondary market premiums. However, Lemax’s lower entry price means less financial stress if you decide to stop collecting or change direction.
Compatibility considerations
Can you mix Department 56 and Lemax? Technically yes. Practically, it requires careful selection.
Scale differences: Department 56 leans slightly larger and more detailed. Lemax buildings sometimes appear smaller or less substantial beside Department 56 pieces.
Style differences: Department 56’s realism contrasts with Lemax’s sometimes more stylized approach.
Lighting differences: Color temperature and brightness can clash when mixed.
For best results, choose one brand as your primary collection and use the other sparingly for accent pieces.
“Choose one brand as your primary collection, then use the other sparingly for accent pieces.”OUR DISPLAY ADVICE
New releases & availability
Department 56 releases new pieces annually, typically in summer. Limited production runs create urgency—popular buildings sell out quickly and may not return. Lemax introduces new pieces more frequently and maintains larger inventories. You’re less likely to face “should have bought it when I saw it” regret.
See newest villages →Storage & Maintenance
DEPARTMENT 56 CARE
Wrap each piece individually in acid-free tissue
Use divided storage boxes
Store in climate-controlled space
Handle gently—porcelain repairs are difficult
Clean with soft brush only
LEMAX CARE
Standard bubble wrap sufficient
More compact storage possible
Temperature less critical
Wipe clean with damp cloth
Minor damage often repairable with super glue
Which brand should you choose?
DEPARTMENT 56 CARE
You want heirloom-quality pieces
You appreciate fine detail and craftsmanship
You don’t mind higher prices
You plan to build a valuable collection
You have secure display and storage space
LEMAX
You want budget-friendly options
You need durability (kids, pets, active households)
You prefer variety and frequent additions
You value practicality over collectibility
You want animated or sound features
Can you start with one and switch?
Yes, but starting with Department 56 and adding Lemax later works better than the reverse. It's easier to "trade down" in price than convince yourself to suddenly spend more per piece. Many collectors own both brands and display them separately—Department 56 for the formal living room, Lemax for the family room or kids' spaces.
Our Recommendation
For most first-time collectors, start with Lemax. Test the hobby without major financial commitment. If you love village collecting after a season or two, invest in Department 56 pieces for your main display.
For serious collectors certain they’ll pursue this long-term, Department 56's quality and collectibility justify the premium.
Either way, you’re buying from established brands with proven track records and widespread support.
Start your collection today →Aug 31st 2026
Jim ShoreHeartwood Creek & Disney
Byers ChoiceHandmade carolers
ENGSTLERNew cuckoo clocks
Dept 56 New for 202650th anniversary pieces
Lemax New for 2026Just arrived
Putz HousesGlittered paper houses
Christmas TreesIt's tree season
WreathsReal-touch greenery
StockingsHang them by the chimney
String LightsWarm white & multi
Novelty LightsSanta heads & fun shapes
Outdoor LightsIcicles & outdoor sets
Holiday SpectacularCircus stripes & carousels
Yuletide TraditionsVintage Santas & plaid
Northern LightsWhite & crystal
Thanksgiving & FallCozy fall & Thanksgiving decor
Valentine's DayHearts & gifts
HalloweenSpooky season
Food & CandyStocking stuffers
Plush ToysSoft & cuddly
GamesFamily game night